WatchLog

How accurate is your mechanical watch?

Updated · By Mathieu Bolard, maker of WatchLog

A mechanical watch’s accuracy is its rate: the number of seconds it gains or loses in a day, written in seconds per day (s/d). A COSC-certified chronometer must stay between −4 and +6 s/d, while the movements in most everyday automatic watches are specified to between ±12 s/d (ETA and Sellita standard grade) and −20 to +40 s/d (Seiko NH, Miyota 8). You can measure the rate yourself by comparing the watch with atomic time a day apart, and read finer detail, beat error and amplitude, on a timegrapher.

How to measure your watch’s accuracy

You need the watch, a source of atomic time and a day. Your phone’s clock is not a reliable reference on its own: it can be a second or more off, so compare against a time server instead.

  1. Wind the watch and wear it as usual

    A fully wound movement runs at its normal rate. Measuring a watch that is about to stop tells you little.

  2. Note its offset against atomic time

    At the moment the seconds hand reaches 12, note how far the watch is ahead of or behind atomic time, to the tenth of a second if you can.

  3. Wait about 24 hours

    The longer the interval, the smaller the effect of your own timing error. A tap a third of a second off is 7 s/d over an hour, but only 0.3 s/d over a day.

  4. Note the offset again

    Repeat the reading the same way, at the same moment of the seconds hand.

  5. Divide the change by the days elapsed

    Rate = (second offset − first offset) ÷ days between them. A watch that was +3.0 s ahead on Monday at 8:00 and +8.5 s ahead on Tuesday at 8:00 gains +5.5 s/d.

Your reaction time is about the same on both readings, so it cancels out of the rate. Log several days in a row to see how consistent the watch is, and note how it rested overnight: dial up, crown down and so on all give slightly different rates. WatchLog does this arithmetic for you: tap when the seconds hand reaches 12 and it stamps the reading with atomic time.

What accuracy is normal for a mechanical watch?

Each certification or movement grade allows a band of daily rates. WatchLog draws these bands on its drift chart; here they are from the strictest to the most lenient.

Accepted daily rate by standard, in seconds per day
StandardAccepted rate
Rolex Superlative Chronometer−2 to +2 s/d
COSC Excellence−2 to +4 s/d
Tudor in-house standard−2 to +4 s/d
METAS Master Chronometer0 to +5 s/d
Grand Seiko Special Standard−3 to +5 s/d
COSC Chronometer−4 to +6 s/d
ETA / Sellita Top grade−4 to +4 s/d
ETA / Sellita Elaboré grade−7 to +7 s/d
ETA / Sellita Standard grade−12 to +12 s/d
Miyota 9 series−10 to +30 s/d
Seiko 6R−15 to +25 s/d
Seiko NH / 4R−20 to +40 s/d
Miyota 8 series−20 to +40 s/d
Vintage, everyday use−30 to +30 s/d

COSC certification tests the bare movement for 15 days in 5 positions and at 3 temperatures. COSC Excellence, METAS Master Chronometer and the makers’ own standards test the cased watch, and COSC Excellence and METAS also test resistance to magnetic fields. A movement grade such as Seiko NH or Miyota 8 is the maker’s specification for a new movement, not a certification.

So a watch that gains 5 seconds a day is within COSC limits, and is a minute fast in under two weeks. One that gains 25 seconds a day is outside every chronometer standard but within the specification of a Seiko NH35.

What is a timegrapher?

A timegrapher, or timing machine, is a watchmaker’s instrument that listens to the ticks of a mechanical movement and computes its rate, beat error and amplitude in seconds, instead of the days a comparison with atomic time takes. Professional machines pick up the tick through a piezo contact sensor clamped to the case.

A phone can do the same through its microphone. It hears the tick through the air, against every other sound in the room, so placement matters: let the crown or case touch the microphone, work in a quiet room, and avoid Bluetooth microphones, whose compression erases the tick. A wired clip-on microphone is a big step up. A phone’s audio clock can also be off by up to about 20 parts per million, around ±1.7 s/d, which WatchLog Pro calibrates out against a watch whose rate you know.

A timegrapher tells you how the watch runs now, in one position. The daily log tells you how it runs over real wear. The two together give the full picture.

What do good timegrapher readings look like?

Timegrapher readings for a standard movement, measured dial up and fully wound
ReadingExcellentGoodFairNeeds attention
Ratewithin ±6 s/d±6 to ±15 s/d±15 to ±30 s/dbeyond ±30 s/d
Beat errorunder 0.5 ms0.5–1.0 ms1.0–2.0 msover 2.0 ms
Amplitude270–310°245–270°210–245°under 200°
Rate
Seconds gained (+) or lost (−) per day in the current position. Beyond ±30 s/d the watch needs regulating, which a watchmaker does by moving the regulator.
Beat error
The time difference between the tic and the toc, in milliseconds. It means the balance doesn’t rest centred on the escapement, which makes the watch more sensitive to position. Over 2 ms it is worth correcting, which a watchmaker does by turning the hairspring stud.
Amplitude
How far the balance wheel swings from rest, in degrees. A healthy movement swings about 270–310° dial up and fully wound; vertical positions read 20–40° lower. Low amplitude means less energy reaches the balance: a tired mainspring, old oil or wear. Under 200°, the watch likely needs a service.
Lift angle
A property of the escapement, typically 48–55°, that the timegrapher needs to compute amplitude. A wrong value shifts amplitude by 10–20% but never affects rate or beat error. Co-axial escapements can’t be measured this way.

What is beat rate (bph)?

Beat rate is how many times the movement ticks in an hour, in beats per hour (bph). Every tick is half an oscillation of the balance, so 28,800 bph is 8 ticks a second, or 4 Hz. A timegrapher has to know it, or detect it, to compute the rate.

Common beat rates
Beat rateTicks per secondFrequencyExamples
18,000 bph52.5 HzETA 6497 / 6498 Unitas, many vintage movements
21,600 bph63 HzSeiko NH35 / 4R36, Seiko 6R35, Miyota 8215
28,800 bph84 HzETA 2824-2, Sellita SW200-1, Valjoux 7750, Miyota 9015, Rolex 3235
36,000 bph105 HzZenith El Primero, Grand Seiko Hi-Beat 9S85

WatchLog detects beat rates from 12,000 to 43,200 bph by ear, and knows the beat rate and lift angle of about 350 calibers from 53 makers.

Why does the rate change with position?

Gravity pulls on the balance differently when the watch is flat or upright. Flat, the balance rests on the end of a pivot and has little friction; upright, it rubs on the side of its pivots and swings less. Any imbalance in the wheel turns into a rate difference.

Watchmakers time a movement in up to six positions. The difference between the fastest and slowest, the positional spread, tells you how well it is adjusted: under 10 s/d is excellent for a standard movement. It is also why the position a watch rests in overnight matters: a watch that gains on the wrist can rest in a position where it loses, and cancel out its drift.

Is my watch magnetized?

A watch that suddenly gains tens of seconds to minutes a day, and runs erratically, has most likely been magnetized. Steel hairsprings pick up magnetism from phones, laptop lids, speakers and bag clasps; the coils stick together and the balance swings short.

  1. Bring a compass close to the watch. If the needle jumps toward it, the watch carries a magnet of its own. An iPhone or iPad’s compass sensor works too: WatchLog’s magnetism check reads it as you turn the watch over the device.
  2. Have it demagnetized. A watchmaker’s demagnetizer takes seconds.
  3. Measure the rate again from a fresh start. The old readings no longer describe the watch.

When does a watch need a service?

Most makers suggest a service every 5 to 10 years. Logging the rate regularly shows the trend long before the watch stops.

Measure yours with WatchLog

WatchLog logs your watch’s daily rate against atomic time and reads rate, beat error and amplitude through the microphone, on iPhone, iPad and Mac. Free for three watches.

Download on the App Store